Explore whether a process can easily be used for additional products or services
Rosemann, M. (2020). Explorative Process Design Patterns. BPM 2020 Proceedings All sources
category: Explorative
The essence of a business process is the interplay of the control flow logic of the process model and the item (e.g., a product, a person) that is processed along the defined process. Exploitative process improvement takes the item for granted and centers on a reductionist approach to streamline the flow of the item.
Process generalization is the exploration of an existing process capability that can be used for additional items; that is, the provision of new products or services with only minor changes to the process. Therefore, process generalization re-purposes (re-uses) a process and facilitates the generation of new value by providing new products or services cost-effectively to the market. Process generalization allows new revenue to be generated from new products or services via the re-use of an existing process capability leading to economies of scope (multiple products/services sharing a process) and a higher return on the process
Put simply, the question is not how to make the process faster or cheaper, but which other items could flow through it. This makes generalization an explorative pattern: it starts from an opportunity, not from a problem in the as-is process.
Unlike in data modeling, the generalization of process models is far less studied. The dominating view is on specialization as the decomposition of a process activity into a sub-process. In order to deploy process generalization, the process designer needs to determine the essential process capability and then identify further items that could capitalize on this capability. As a process pattern (Fig. 2), one could think of process generalization as a way to add new tokens to an existing process model. While most organizations first create a new service or product and then build the required processes related to procurement, production, and distribution (‘process follows product’), process generalization represents a ‘product follows process’ paradigm.
Process expansion is the complementary move: generalization adds new items to an existing process, while expansion adds new activities to it. Process Differentiation, by contrast, keeps the item and nuances the process qualities.
Framed along the FLAC rule types — fitness, location, attribute, constraint.
Generalization is explorative, so event data supports rather than drives the idea. Fitness: Mature, stable processes that handle one or a few product or service types and have spare capacity. Location: The core sequence of activities that does not depend on the specific item, i.e. steps that look the same across product types. Attributes: Variant similarity across existing product types (if two products share most of the path, a third may too), resource utilisation and idle time, and the share of item-specific activities. Constraints: Don’t generalise where a new item would need substantial control-flow changes, where regulatory requirements differ, or where extra volume would hurt the service level of the existing products.
Foundational free Patterns
Elevate physical constraints by applying new technology
Consider the division of a general activity into two or more alternative activities
Assign a responsible individual for handling each case type
Let workers perform as many steps as possible for single cases
Consider automating activities
Automate for environmental impact
Implement automation in a sustainable way
Buffer external information and subscribe to updates
Combine small activities into composite activities
Collect similar work items and work in batches
Constraint-based task assignment
Allocate tasks considering business process execution constraints
Process expansion is an assessment to test, if an existing process could create additional value by adding further activities to the process.