Process expansion is an assessment to test, if an existing process could create additional value by adding further activities to the process.
Rosemann, M. (2020). Explorative Process Design Patterns. BPM 2020 Proceedings All sources
Scoping a process is one of the most fundamental process design decisions. The more comprehensive the scope, the higher is the potential to generate, and charge for, additional value for customers. As such, process expansion is in sharp contrast to established, reductionist value-stream mapping approaches, which focus on identifying those activities that do not add value and are then targets for elimination.
Process expansion is an assessment to test, if an existing process could create additional value by adding further activities to the process. Such an expansion needs to be grounded in a competitive advantage, for example, the availability of data that facilitates the process expansion. The organization creates new billable value in addition to the value proposition of the existing process.
In this sense, expansion is the explorative counterpart to Eliminate activities: it argues for adding value-creating steps rather than removing non-value-adding ones. Generalize your process is its sibling; generalization adds new items to an existing process, expansion adds new activities.
When an organization deploys process expansion, it adds new activities to the process. These activities can be visible to the customer or not and could be at the start (see Fig. 3) or at the end of the process.
Food delivery companies such as Deliveroo, DoorDash, UberEats or Swiggy offer an order-to-delivery process. Their process capability consists of the ability to take a food order, to source the food from a provider, transport and deliver the food to the customer, process the payment and facilitate a customer rating. While conventional, exploitative process improvement techniques would seek streamlining (e.g., tour optimization) or modernizing (e.g., voice-enabled ordering) this process capability, process expansion encourages to look beyond the existing process boundaries by capitalizing on available data. In the case of food delivery companies, these are the location-sensitive purchase orders of customers. This dataset provides insights into what types of food are popular in what areas and into the average distance between the restaurant and the customer. An analysis of this geoinformation points to popular types of food with high delivery times. It is exactly this type of analysis that has motivated many of these food delivery companies to open dark (or ghost) kitchens, i.e. setting up new places where food is produced for the exclusive purpose of food delivery. A similar example for process expansion is Netflix entering the market for the production of content based on customer preferences and so called micro-genres. As indicated, process expansion might also occur at the end of a process and by this further add activities beyond the existing end of the process. This will be in particular the case, if a continuous connectivity can be established [34], i.e. via a sensor the product-providing company stays in touch with the customer (e.g., Tesla continues to sell upgrades to its customers after the purchase of the car).
Guidelines – Process designers interested in exploring process expansion need to assess the datasets which are emerging within the process. This will often mean evaluating the contents of the triggering event, for example, purchase orders. This data then needs to be evaluated in terms of its competitive insight, i.e. does producing rather than sourcing provide a path to new value? Processes that could trigger a consideration of process expansion are high volume processes with start events that have a high number of attributes. These attributes need to inform a possible process expansion, e.g. point to products or services in demand.
Framed along the FLAC rule types — fitness, location, attribute, constraint.
Fitness: High-volume processes whose start events carry many attributes, as the guideline suggests, e.g. order-to-delivery or service processes. Location: The process boundaries, i.e. what happens just before the start event and after the end event, and steps currently sourced from partners. Attributes: Attributes of the triggering event (products, locations, quantities, timing) aggregated to reveal demand hot spots, long lead times for popular items, and repeat requests after case completion. Constraints: Expand only where the data gives you a genuine advantage, where you can build the capability, and where competing with your own partners or suppliers is acceptable.
Foundational free Patterns
Elevate physical constraints by applying new technology
Consider the division of a general activity into two or more alternative activities
Assign a responsible individual for handling each case type
Let workers perform as many steps as possible for single cases
Consider automating activities
Automate for environmental impact
Implement automation in a sustainable way
Buffer external information and subscribe to updates
Combine small activities into composite activities
Collect similar work items and work in batches
Constraint-based task assignment
Allocate tasks considering business process execution constraints