Specialist-generalist

Consider to deepen or broaden the skills of resources

Reijers, H., & Liman Mansar, S. (2005). Best practices in business process redesign: an overview and qualitative evaluation of successful redesign heuristics. Omega, 33(4) All sources

category: Organization class: Allocation Rules frameworkAspect: Organizational Population perspective: organizational/resource

Description

This pattern looks at the skill profile of the people in your process rather than at the activities themselves.

Resources may be turned from specialists into generalists or the other way round. A specialist resource can be trained for other qualifications; a generalist may be assigned to the same type of work for a longer period of time, so that his other qualifications become obsolete. When the redesign of a new process is considered, application of the pattern comes down to considering the specialist-generalist ratio of new hires.

A specialist builds up routine more quickly and may have a more profound knowledge than a generalist. As a result he or she works quicker and delivers higher quality. On the other hand, the availability of generalists adds more flexibility to the process and can lead to a better utilization of resources. Depending on the degree of specialism or generalism, either type of resource may be more costly.

The choice is rarely all-or-nothing. A common design is a core of specialists for complex or high-volume work, complemented by a few generalists who step in where queues build up; the evidence cited in the source excerpt below indicates that a small number of generalists may improve performance, while adding more does not necessarily yield further benefit.

Note that this heuristic differs from the Triage concept in the sense that the focus is not on the division of tasks.

Broadening skills also supports Flexible assignment, because each generalist widens the set of activities to which work can be allocated.

Poyssick and Hannaford (1996) and Berg and Pottjewijd (1997) stress the advantages of generalists. Rupp and Russell (1994), Seidmann and Sundararajan (1997), and Reijers and Goverde (1998) mention both specialists and generalists. Van der Wal (1997) provides some insight into the use of generalists (“butter-flies”). For the example he uses, it follows that a small number of generalists may indeed improve the performance of a system, but increasing this number does not yield additional benefits.

Key Takeaways

  1. Deepen or broaden — Decide per role whether routine and depth or breadth and mobility serve the process better.
  2. A few generalists go far — A small group of cross-trained workers can absorb fluctuations without diluting specialist expertise.
  3. Match to demand variability — Stable, high-volume work favours specialists; volatile demand across activity types favours generalists.
  4. Consider the people — Cross-training can counter monotony and support development, but takes time and must suit individual preferences.

Performance considerations

Specialists tend to improve time and quality for the work they specialise in, through routine and deeper knowledge. Generalists improve flexibility: they can be moved to where work piles up, which shortens queues when demand fluctuates and improves utilisation. Cost depends on training effort and the labour market, since either profile can be the more expensive one. Overall, the pattern lets you move between the time-and-quality and the flexibility corners of the Devil’s Quadrangle. A mixed workforce, sized with historic workload data or simulation, often balances both. Narrow specialisation can also lead to monotonous work, which affects motivation and, in turn, quality.

Example

For example, a customer service centre could organise its agents in separate queues for billing, technical issues and contract changes, each staffed with specialists. When a price change floods the billing queue, technical agents may sit idle while billing customers wait. Cross-training a small group of agents in both billing and technical topics lets them move to whichever queue is longest, while the specialists keep handling the complex cases in their domain.

Spotting the opportunity in event data

Framed along the FLAC rule types — fitness, location, attribute, constraint.

Fitness: processes with fluctuating demand per activity type and resources tied to narrow sets of activities. Location: activities with long queues while other resources in the same unit are underutilised; activities with long processing times when performed by infrequent performers. Attributes: distinct activities per resource, utilisation per resource over time, waiting time per activity, processing time and rework by resource experience (execution frequency). Constraints: activities requiring certification or deep expertise; training cost and lead time; resources’ preferences and workload.

Sources & references

  1. Reijers, H., & Liman Mansar, S. (2005). Best practices in business process redesign: an overview and qualitative evaluation of successful redesign heuristics. Omega, 33(4) Summary on this site Publisher page DOI 10.1016/j.omega.2004.04.012

Share this pattern

Related Pairings

Premium Service

Provide exceptional service experiences for premium customers

Read more

Enjoy these

Foundational free Patterns

Apply Integral technology

Elevate physical constraints by applying new technology

Apply triage

Consider the division of a general activity into two or more alternative activities

Appoint case managers

Assign a responsible individual for handling each case type

Assign cases

Let workers perform as many steps as possible for single cases

Automate activities

Consider automating activities

Automate for environmental impact

Implement automation in a sustainable way

Buffer information

Buffer external information and subscribe to updates

Combine activities

Combine small activities into composite activities

Consolidate Work

Collect similar work items and work in batches

Constraint-based task assignment

Allocate tasks considering business process execution constraints

← Back

Connected to

Apply triage

Consider the division of a general activity into two or more alternative activities

What's Happening?

Dec 2023
New Pattern

Consolidate Work

Nov 2023
Oct 2023
Oct 2023
New Cheat sheet

Redesign Essentials

Sep 2023
Sep 2023
Aug 2023
New Pattern

Task delegation

Aug 2023
Aug 2023
New Pattern

Green Feature

Aug 2023