Explorative process design patterns

This study proposes seven explorative process design patterns derived from secondary data analysis.

Rosemann, M. (2020). Explorative Process Design Patterns. BPM 2020 Proceedings

Research paper

This study proposes seven explorative process design patterns derived from secondary data analysis.

These patterns aim to identify value creation opportunities in existing processes, offering a more balanced perspective alongside operationally excellent processes, thereby fostering revenue-resilient business models.

Citation: Rosemann, M. (2020). Explorative Process Design Patterns. BPM 2020 Proceedings Read: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-030-58666-9_20

Content

The text discusses overprocessing waste in business processes and highlights the use of knock-out checks to identify and eliminate this waste. A novel, interpretable process mining approach is proposed to detect improvement opportunities and recommend process redesigns. The paper presents an implemented software tool and showcases its applicability on real-life processes.

Knock-Out Checks and Overprocessing

Knock-out checks are tasks in a business process that classify cases as either “accepted” or “rejected”. If a case is rejected, it triggers the execution of an anchor, a pre-determined point in the process, effectively ending the process. When a knock-out check leads to a case’s rejection, all the work up to that point is deemed overprocessing waste, leading to inefficiency in terms of time and cost.

Knock-Out Check Discovery and Analysis

The proposed method uses an event log to discover and analyze knock-out checks. The process involves discovering knock-out checks, their decision rules, and dependencies from the event log, then assessing overprocessing waste and effort-per-rejection rates. It supports three modes of operation: semi-automatic discovery, automatic discovery, and known knock-out checks.

Improvement Opportunity Identification

The final step is to identify improvement opportunities and suggest possible redesigns based on the knock-out checks. These redesigns include knock-out reordering (least effort to reject), knock-out relocation (earliest possible point), and knock-out rule adjustment (changing attribute values).

Overall, the process mining approach provides insight into process redesign opportunities to reduce overprocessing waste. The interpretability of the results supports decision-making and increases confidence in redesign recommendations.

License

Open Access The original manuscript is licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as appropriate credit is given the original author(s) and the source. We have condensed parts of the text to provide the hightlights.

Patterns from this research

  • Generalize your process — Explore whether a process can easily be used for additional products or services
  • Process Differentiation — Process differentiation is the creation of one or more additional process variants with the aim to offer a new value proposition for a subset of the existing process customers or to attract entire new customers to the process.
  • Process expansion — Process expansion is an assessment to test, if an existing process could create additional value by adding further activities to the process.
  • Process Initiation — Process initiation is the exploration of how new data sources can be used to reduce process latency, i.e.
  • Process Commercialization — Process commercialization is an assessment, if there is a market external to the organization that would be interested in deploying the entire process, or relevant parts of it, as a service.
← Back

Share this

Patterns related to this item

Generalize your process

Explore whether a process can easily be used for additional products or services

Process expansion

Process expansion is an assessment to test, if an existing process could create additional value by adding further activities to the process.